Excellent sound is vital if you like listening to music or podcasts in your car. Good sound can make the difference between enjoying audio-related media and feeling like you are listening to nails on a chalkboard. With that in mind, it is important to understand what distinguishes good from bad sound in speakers. This knowledge is not exclusive to technical people only.
Even the layperson has preferences regarding sound, even though they may not know its technical jargon.
When it comes to car stereos, there are a lot of factors that come into play concerning sound quality. However, the two most important factors are whether the speaker is a component or a coaxial speaker.
So if you are in the market for a new car speaker or want to upgrade, we have curated a directory to guide you in making a choice.
What Is A Component Speaker?
Component speakers provide excellent precision in terms of the individual sounds they produce. Commonly a pair of tweeters and mid-bass drivers are harmonized with a crossover to cut down the frequency range each speaker must precisely reproduce.
Pros of Component Speakers
- Superior sound quality
- More accurate frequency reproduction
- Greater control over sound volume and clarity
- Improved dynamic range and stereo imaging
Cons of Component Speakers
- Cost more than other speaker systems
- Installation can be complicated without professional assistance
What Is A Coaxial Speaker?
Coaxial speakers are ideal for those seeking high-quality audio in a compact, budget-friendly package. They offer a more immersive sound experience without compromising clarity and accuracy, making them perfect for listening over long periods.
Pros of Coaxial Speakers
- More compact design
- Better sound clarity
- Good range and accuracy throughout frequencies
- Generally more affordable than other component systems
Cons of Coaxial Speakers
- Less power than other component speakers
- Prone to distortion at higher volumes
Read more: Best Floor Standing Speakers Under $500
Similarities Between Component and Coaxial Speakers
No matter the speaker type, component and coaxial speakers have a few similarities. Both speakers use magnets to create sound waves in response to electrical signals. Additionally, each can be connected to an audio system for playback.
The most important thing these two speakers have in common is that they were both made for the same reason: to make incredible sounds from audio signals. Choosing a component or coaxial speaker will ultimately depend on your needs and budget.
Both have tweeters and woofers that work together to make a sound when electrical signals from an amplifier or stereo system are sent to them. The tweeter creates a higher-frequency sound, while the woofer delivers lower frequencies. Together, they help make sounds that feel like they came from real life and have a good balance of high and low frequencies.
Also, you usually put both speakers in the same place, like in your car or home entertainment system. With the correct setup, you can have great-sounding audio regardless of which type you choose.
Differences Between Component And Coaxial Speakers
The main difference between component and coaxial speakers is their design. While both speakers have tweeter and woofer components, a component speaker separates them into two different units, while coaxial speakers combine them into one unit.
Component speakers give you a better sound experience because they are made of separate parts designed to work together to make a balanced, detailed soundstage.
Combining tweeters, midranges, woofers, and crossovers ensures that all frequencies are accurately reproduced, and amplifiers give you more control over your audio system. So if you’re looking for a high-quality listening experience, consider investing in a component speaker system.
It gives you more options and customizations for the sound quality because each part can be changed separately for more accuracy. Moreover, component speakers generate a more expansive sound than their coaxial counterparts.
On the other hand, coaxial speakers are designed for convenience and affordability. Coaxial speakers are easier to set up and have fewer parts overall because all parts are built into one unit. And this makes them more budget-friendly as well as more user-friendly.
Coaxial speakers have a woofer and a tweeter attached and can’t be adjusted separately. Instead, they rely on their simple design to create a more uniform sound. Due to their compact size, coaxial speakers fit into many different spaces. They also offer excellent clarity for longer listening sessions.
This can be beneficial, especially in cars where space is often limited. Also, these speakers are usually cheaper than options made up of separate parts because they need fewer parts.
Why Is It Important to Know the Difference Between Component and Coaxial Speakers?
You should know the difference if you want a fantastic sound that appeals to your eardrums. For this guide, we will look at two premium options to help add gravitas to the comparison.
Component vs. Coaxial Speakers Summary
| Image | Model | Price |
|---|---|---|
|
Skar Audio TX35 2-Way Elite Coaxial Car Speakers | See On Amazon |
|
JBL GTO609C Premium 6.5-Inch Component Speaker System | See On Amazon |
Component vs. Coaxial Speakers Reviews
Skar Audio TX35 2-Way Elite Coaxial Car Speakers
SPECIFICATIONS
RMS Power: 60 Watts (Pair) | Max Power: 120 Watts (Pair) | Impedance: 4 Ohms | Sold as a Pair | 1" (25.4mm) High Grade Silk Dome Tweeter | Glass Fiber Cone | 1" Copper Voice Coil | Frequency Response: 145 Hz - 20,000 Hz | Sensitivity: 84 dB | Mounting Depth: 1.625" | Cutout Diameter: 2.95"
REASONS TO BUY
✓ Excellent sound quality and power for the price
✓ Built-in tweeters and woofers for superior audio reproduction
✓ Heavy and good-sized magnet for easier installation
REASONS TO AVOID
✗ Not as powerful as component systems
✗ On rare occasions, the bracket metal can become loose
The Skar Audio TX35 2-Way Elite Coaxial Car Speakers is an excellent option if you’re looking for a great-sounding, compact design without breaking the bank. The built-in tweeters and woofers provide crisp highs and rich lows. There’s also a larger magnet than usual for easy installation, and the speaker system as a whole is durable.
Though it may not be as powerful as some component systems, this speaker is an excellent choice for those on a budget.
JBL GTO609C Premium 6.5-Inch Component Speaker System
SPECIFICATIONS
GTO 609C (Two-way) 6-1/2" (165mm) | Peak power handling: 270W | Power handling: 75W | RMS Recommended power: 5W – 200W RMS | Frequency response: 67Hz – 21kHz | Nominal impedance: 3 ohms | Sensitivity (2.83V/1m): 92dB
REASONS TO BUY
✓ Excellent sound quality across all frequencies
✓ Designed to reduce distortion at higher volumes
✓ Affordable price point compared to other component systems
REASONS TO AVOID
✗ The larger size makes it harder to install in some locations
The JBL GTO609C Premium 6.5-Inch Component Speaker System is one of the best component speaker systems on the market. It includes two separate tweeters and woofers, allowing superior sound reproduction across all frequencies.
Plus, its components are designed to reduce distortion at higher volumes, so you can enjoy crystal-clear audio no matter how loud your music turns up. Finally, its price point makes it an excellent option for those looking for a top-notch system without spending too much money.
Coaxial or Component Speakers: Which One Should You Pick?
This ultimately comes down to personal preference and the needs of your audio system. Component speakers give you more control over how they spread the sound around a room or car. Coaxial speakers are easier to use and less expensive. A component system might be the way to go if you’re looking for better sound quality.
However, coaxial speakers might be a better option if installation is an issue. No matter your speaker type, both component and coaxial speakers can provide great-sounding audio.
No matter what kind of speakers you choose, if you set them up and use the right tools, you can create an immersive listening experience.
Both options are sure to bring your listening experience to the next level. Still, we recommend coaxial speakers as they give more for the money.
Read more: The Best 10-Inch Subwoofers Under $100
